Skip to main content

The Ultimate Guide to America’s Most Popular Pizzerias in 2023

The Ultimate Guide to America’s Most Popular Pizzerias in 2023

Pizza is undoubtedly one of America’s favorite foods, and with so many pizzerias offering their unique spin on this classic dish, it’s no wonder that people are constantly on the lookout for the best places to grab a slice. In this article, we’ll be exploring the most popular pizzerias in the USA for 2023, providing you with a mouthwatering guide to fulfill your pizza cravings. But if you’re in the mood for something a bit different, check out our delicious homemade bagel pizza recipe for a creative twist on the classic pizza.

Pizza Days #

Location: Burlington, Massachusetts

See Pizza Days’s Menu


Pizza Days is a popular pizza joint located in Burlington, Massachusetts. This pizzeria offers a variety of mouth-watering pizzas, including classics like Margherita and Pepperoni, as well as unique combinations such as Buffalo Chicken and Greek Pizza. In addition to their scrumptious pizza offerings, Pizza Days also serves delicious pasta dishes, salads, and sandwiches to cater to all cravings. The friendly atmosphere and delectable menu items make this spot a must-visit for anyone in the area.

Godfather’s Pizza #

Location: Various locations across the United States

See Godfather’s Pizza’s Menu

Godfather's Pizza

Established in 1973, Godfather’s Pizza is a well-known pizza chain with locations all across the United States. Renowned for their hearty pizzas and inviting atmosphere, Godfather’s Pizza offers an extensive menu featuring a variety of specialty pies like the Classic Combo, Taco Pizza, and their signature pie – The Don – loaded with delicious toppings. Alongside their pizza selections, customers can enjoy a range of appetizers, sides, and desserts. With over 40 years of experience, Godfather’s Pizza continues to be a favorite among pizza enthusiasts.

Pegasus Pizza #

Location: Eugene and Whiteaker, Oregon

See Pegasus Pizza’s Menu

Pegasus Pizza

Located in the charming neighborhoods of Eugene and Whiteaker, Oregon, Pegasus Pizza offers a delightful mix of classic and gourmet pizzas to its customers. This family-owned and operated pizzeria has been serving the locals since 1989, and is known for using only the freshest ingredients in their pizza and pasta dishes. The crowd favorites in this pizzeria include the Chicken Zorba Pizza and the Pegasus Extravaganza. With a welcoming atmosphere and a strong commitment to deliciousness, Pegasus Pizza remains a beloved option for pizza lovers in the area.

Blasdell Pizza #

Location: Blasdell and Hamburg, New York

See Blasdell Pizza’s Menu

Blasdell Pizza

With locations in Blasdell and Hamburg, New York, Blasdell Pizza has been serving delicious pizza and more to its loyal customers since 1978. Known for their crispy crust and flavorful sauce, Blasdell Pizza offers a diverse menu featuring classic pizza favorites, specialty pies, chicken wings, subs, and more. Beyond their delicious pizza, this pizzeria is well known for its commitment to community engagement and providing exceptional customer service.

Gramma’s Pizza #

Location: Various locations in Kentucky and Ohio

See Gramma’s Pizza’s Menu

Gramma's Pizza

Gramma’s Pizza, with locations in Kentucky and Ohio, has been offering mouthwatering pizzas and Italian favorites to its customers for over 40 years. Boasting a cozy atmosphere reminiscent of grandma’s kitchen, this family-owned pizzeria creates specialty pizzas such as BBQ Chicken, Philly Steak, and Sweet and Spicy Hawaiian. Alongside their vast pizza menu, Gramma’s Pizza also offers a tempting selection of pasta dishes, calzones, and sandwiches.

Fairmount Pizza #

Location: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

See Fairmount Pizza’s Menu

Fairmount Pizza

Located in the heart of Philadelphia’s Fairmount neighborhood, Fairmount Pizza has earned a reputation for its delicious, generously topped pizzas and warm, inviting environment. This family-owned pizzeria offers an array of menu items, including gourmet pizzas, classic pies, Italian entrées, and an extensive selection of hot and cold sandwiches. For over 20 years, Fairmount Pizza has been a favorite among locals and visitors alike, serving up delicious dishes with a side of friendly service.

All American Pizza #

Location: Oklahoma

See All American Pizza’s Menu

All American Pizza

All American Pizza offers a traditional pizzeria experience, serving delicious pizzas made with fresh ingredients. With locations across Oklahoma, the pizzeria strives to provide a family-friendly atmosphere where everyone can gather and enjoy a great meal. The menu offers various pizza flavors, including classic pepperoni, meat lovers, or the popular All-American special with various toppings.

Pink’s Pizza #

Location: Houston, Texas

See Pink’s Pizza’s Menu

Pink's Pizza

Pink’s Pizza, located in Houston, is known for its hand-tossed, made-from-scratch pizzas, featuring a deliciously unique crust and an extensive selection of toppings and specialty pies. The menu ranges from traditional favorites like Margherita and pepperoni to more innovative creations like the Mediterranean-inspired Santorini pizza. Pink’s Pizza also has gluten-free options available for those with dietary restrictions.

Eagle One Pizza #

Location: Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

See Eagle One Pizza’s Menu

Eagle One Pizza

Eagle One Pizza is a top-rated pizzeria in Oklahoma City, known for offering a wide variety of delicious, made-to-order pizzas. With a diverse menu featuring classics like the Supreme or Hawaiian to more unique options like the Philly Cheesesteak pizza, there’s something for everyone at Eagle One Pizza. Alongside their famous pizzas, they also offer calzones, sandwiches, and a selection of appetizers.

Brixx Pizza #

Location: Multiple locations in Southeastern United States

See Brixx Pizza’s Menu

Brixx Pizza

With locations throughout the southeastern United States, Brixx Pizza offers wood-fired brick oven pizzas made with fresh ingredients. Known for their unique, thin crust, Brixx Pizza offers an array of original flavors with creative topping combinations as well as vegan and gluten-free options. The pizzeria also features a full bar and a selection of appetizers and desserts to complement your meal.

Me N Eds Pizza #

Location: California

See Me N Eds Pizza’s menu

Me N Eds Pizza

Me N Eds Pizza is a popular pizzeria in California, known for its delicious, handmade pizzas with fresh, locally sourced ingredients. With over 50 years of experience, Me N Eds Pizza has perfected their crust and toppings to create signature flavors, such as the classic combo and the Stockyard Special. The pizzeria also offers wings, salads, and desserts to complete the dining experience.

Southside Flying Pizza #

Location: Austin, Texas

See Southside Flying Pizza’s Menu

Southside Flying Pizza

Southside Flying Pizza in Austin, Texas, prides itself on delivering the finest pies in the area, with their unique blend of traditional and sometimes off-the-wall toppings. From classics like Margherita or pepperoni to specialty options like the Southsider, which features jalapeños, pineapples, and cream cheese, there’s something for everyone’s taste buds at Southside Flying Pizza.

Hot Stuff Pizza #

Location: Multiple locations in the United States

See Hot Stuff Pizza’s Menu

Hot Stuff Pizza

Hot Stuff Pizza, with locations across America, is the perfect choice for those looking for a delicious meal on the go. Known for their speedy service and consistently mouth-watering pizzas, Hot Stuff offers a variety of classic and specialty pies, as well as other grab-and-go foods like sandwiches and breakfast items to cater to everyone’s needs.

Mugs Pizza #

Location: Illinois

See Mugs Pizza’s Menu

Mugs Pizza

Mugs Pizza is a family-owned pizzeria in Illinois, known for their authentic Chicago-style pizza. With over 30 years of experience, Mugs Pizza has become a local favorite, offering not only delicious pizza but also ribs, chicken, pasta, and sandwiches. The signature Mug’s Pizza, featuring sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, and mozzarella, is a must-try for any visitor.

Protos Pizza #

Location: Colorado

See Protos Pizza’s Menu

Protos Pizza

Protos Pizza is a Colorado-based pizzeria that specializes in thin-crust, Neapolitan-style pizzas baked in a traditional wood-fired oven. Their menu features a range of classic and artisanal toppings and combinations, as well as a selection of salads, appetizers, and desserts. If you’re a fan of thin crust pizza with a perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and fresh ingredients, Protos Pizza will not disappoint.

Stone Hot Pizza #

Location: Virginia

See Stone Hot Pizza’s Menu

Stone Hot Pizza

Stone Hot Pizza is a gourmet pizzeria in Virginia, offering delicious, fresh pizzas cooked in a wood-fired oven. Their menu includes classic options like Margherita and pepperoni, as well as unique specialty pies like the Chicken Bacon Ranch and Veggie Lover. In addition to pizza, Stone Hot Pizza offers a wide variety of appetizers, pastas, and salads to complete the dining experience.

Big City Pizza #

Location: Kentucky

See Big City Pizza’s Menu

Big City Pizza

Big City Pizza in Kentucky is all about delivering a big city taste to a small-town setting. Offering a unique gourmet pizza dining experience, the menu includes a mixture of traditional favorites and innovative, flavorful creations. From the classics like Cheese or Pepperoni to more daring options like the Loaded Potato pizza, there’s something for every pizza lover at Big City Pizza.

MM MM Pizza #

Location: Pennsylvania

See MM MM Pizza’s Menu

MM MM Pizza

MM MM Pizza, located in Pennsylvania, is a family-owned pizzeria that prides itself on offering a diverse menu filled with mouthwatering pizzas, wings, salads, and more. With decades of experience, MM MM Pizza has developed a dedicated following enjoying their fresh, delicious creations like the MM MM Works, which features a plethora of toppings piled high on a perfect, crispy crust.

Center Court Pizza #

Location: Texas

See Center Court Pizza’s Menu

Center Court Pizza

Center Court Pizza, with locations in Texas, offers a unique sports-themed dining experience where guests can enjoy delicious pizzas and ice-cold beverages while watching their favorite teams on giant screens. Their menu caters to all pizza fans, featuring a variety of classic and unique toppings and combinations, as well as salads, sandwiches, and delectable appetizers.

Teresa’s Pizza #

Location: Ohio

See Teresa’s Pizza’s Menu

Teresa's Pizza

Teresa’s Pizza, a popular Ohio pizzeria, has been serving the community for over 50 years with top-quality pizza and other Italian dishes. Famous for their crispy crust and homemade sauce, Teresa’s Pizza offers a diverse menu of not only classic and specialty pizzas but also subs, wings, salads, and pasta dishes to satisfy every craving.

Bakers Pizza #

Location: Ohio

See Bakers Pizza’s Menu

Bakers Pizza

Bakers Pizza is a popular pizzeria in Ohio, known for its unique stuffed pizzas and outstanding customer service. Their menu offers an array of classic and specialty pies, stuffed or topped with the freshest ingredients, as well as sandwiches, salads, and appetizers. When visiting Bakers Pizza, make sure to try their famous stuffed pizza for an unforgettable meal.

The Pizza Place #

Location: Blue Springs

See The Pizza Place’s Menu

The Pizza Place has earned its spot as a favorite among pizza enthusiasts not only for its cozy atmosphere but also for its commitment to using only the highest quality ingredients. This dedication to quality is evident in every aspect of their offerings, from their hand-tossed dough made fresh daily to their homemade sauce that boasts a perfect balance of flavors.

The Pizza Place offers a wide range of gourmet toppings and specialty pies that cater to every palate. From classic combinations like Margherita and pepperoni to more innovative options like their white pizza topped with ricotta, garlic, and spinach, there’s something for everyone at The Pizza Place. If you’re a fan of customization, you can also build your own pie from their impressive list of fresh ingredients.

In addition to their delicious pizzas, The Pizza Place also serves a variety of mouthwatering appetizers, salads, and desserts. Start your meal with their famous garlic knots or a classic Caesar salad and finish it off with a slice of their indulgent New York-style cheesecake.

The Pizza Place’s genuine commitment to exceptional quality, warm ambiance, and unrivaled customer service make it a must-visit destination for pizza lovers everywhere.

Dan’s Pizza #

Location: Downers Grove

See Dan’s Pizza’s Menu

Dan’s Pizza has built a reputation for serving up delicious, authentic New York-style pizza that keeps customers coming back for more. From the moment you walk into Dan’s Pizza, you’re greeted with the mouthwatering aroma of freshly baked pies, the lively chatter of satisfied customers, and the sight of expert pizza makers hand-tossing dough to perfection.

With a crispy crust that’s thin enough to fold, flavorful sauce made from the finest tomatoes, and generous toppings that range from the classic pepperoni to more adventurous options like sun-dried tomatoes and goat cheese, Dan’s Pizza has something for everyone. One of the fan favorites is their famous buffalo chicken pizza, featuring spicy Buffalo sauce, tender chicken, and a drizzle of creamy ranch dressing.

Dan’s Pizza also offers a variety of specialty pies, such as the Veggie Delight, loaded with fresh vegetables, and the Meat Lovers, piled high with various meats. If you have dietary restrictions, don’t worry – Dan’s Pizza offers gluten-free and vegan options to accommodate all customers.

With its top-notch ingredients, warm and welcoming atmosphere, and consistently delicious pies, Dan’s Pizza is an essential stop on any pizza lover’s journey.

Portofino Pizza #

Location: Chicago

See Portofino Pizza’s Menu


Portofino Pizza brings the taste of Italy to your neighborhood with its authentic Neapolitan-style pies. Featuring a thin, chewy crust that is both crispy and tender, Portofino Pizza prides itself on using traditional pizza-making techniques. The pies are baked in a wood-fired oven, resulting in a perfectly charred crust that’s full of flavor.

Topped with high-quality ingredients sourced both locally and from Italy, Portofino Pizza’s menu offers a range of options, from the classic Margherita topped with fresh basil, mozzarella, and tomatoes, to inventive specialty pies that cater to diverse tastes. In addition to pizza, Portofino offers a variety of antipasti, salads, and pasta dishes to complete your Italian dining experience.

The pizzeria’s warm, inviting atmosphere makes it the perfect spot for a casual meal with friends or family. With friendly staff and an attention to detail, Portofino Pizza ensures that each visit is a memorable one.

Uptown Pizza #

Location: New York

See Uptown Pizza’s Menu

uptow pizza ny

Uptown Pizza is a trendy hot spot known for its innovative, artisanal pizza creations. With a focus on unique flavor combinations and high-quality ingredients, this pizzeria offers an upscale dining experience for pizza lovers. Each pie is expertly crafted by skilled chefs who are passionate about delivering a culinary experience that is both delicious and memorable.

The menu at Uptown Pizza features an array of gourmet toppings, from truffle oil-infused mushrooms to artisanal cheeses and fresh herbs. Don’t miss their signature truffle oil-infused pies or their dessert pizzas, perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth. With options like Nutella and fresh fruit, these dessert pizzas are a must-try for anyone looking to indulge in a truly unique treat.

The stylish interior of Uptown Pizza, with its exposed brick walls and modern lighting, creates a chic and comfortable ambiance that’s perfect for date nights, gatherings with friends, or even a solo outing to enjoy some of the finest pizza in town.

Sofia’s Pizza #

Location: New York

See Sofia’s Pizza’s Menu

For a taste of Old World Italian charm, visit Sofia’s Pizza. This family-owned pizzeria prides itself on serving authentic, homemade recipes passed down through generations. With a cozy, rustic atmosphere and an extensive menu of traditional Italian dishes, Sofia’s Pizza offers a dining experience that feels like a trip to Italy.

The pizza menu at Sofia’s showcases a variety of well-loved classics, such as the Quattro Stagioni, featuring a medley of seasonal ingredients, and the Calabrese, topped with spicy salami and fresh mozzarella. All pizzas are crafted with care, using time-honored techniques and the finest ingredients to ensure a truly authentic taste.

In addition to their outstanding pizza, Sofia’s offers a selection of pasta dishes, such as homemade lasagna and fettuccine Alfredo, as well as a range of antipasti, salads, and desserts. The wine list features a carefully curated selection of Italian wines, perfect for pairing with your meal.

The warm, welcoming atmosphere at Sofia’s Pizza, combined with their commitment to quality and tradition, ensures that every visit is a true Italian culinary experience. With exceptional service and a genuine dedication to the art of pizza-making, Sofia’s Pizza is a must-visit for those seeking an unforgettable dining experience.

Woody’s Pizza #

Location: Boston

See Woody’s Pizza’s Menu

woodys pizza

Woody’s Pizza, a beloved local institution, has been serving up delicious pizza for decades. Known for their crispy, thin-crust pies and laid-back atmosphere, Woody’s Pizza is the perfect place to enjoy a casual meal with friends or family. Their menu features a wide range of toppings and specialty pies, ensuring there’s something for everyone.

At Woody’s Pizza, you can expect not only mouthwatering pizzas but also a warm and welcoming environment that keeps customers coming back for more. The friendly staff and prompt service make every visit a pleasant experience. In addition to their classic Margherita and Pepperoni pizzas, Woody’s also offers a variety of unique combinations such as the Buffalo Chicken pizza or Mediterranean Veggie pizza. For those who prefer a lighter option, Woody’s provides several salad choices, as well as appetizers like garlic knots and mozzarella sticks to complete your meal. With a commitment to using only the freshest ingredients, Woody’s Pizza guarantees a satisfying and memorable dining experience.

Revolver Pizza #

Location: Santa Barbara

See Revolver Pizza’s Menu

revolver pizza

Revolver Pizza is known for its creative, gourmet pies and wood-fired crusts. With a menu that changes seasonally to showcase the freshest ingredients, this pizzeria offers a truly unique dining experience. Some fan favorites include the pear and gorgonzola pizza or the prosciutto and arugula pizza. Don’t forget to save room for their decadent dessert pizzas, like the Nutella and banana pie.

At Revolver Pizza, the chefs pride themselves on pushing the boundaries of traditional pizza-making by incorporating unexpected and bold flavors into their creations. Their innovative approach has gained them a loyal following of customers who appreciate the attention to detail and care that goes into each pie. In addition to their remarkable pizzas, Revolver Pizza also offers a selection of appetizers, salads, and pasta dishes that cater to a variety of tastes. The stylish and modern decor, combined with attentive service, creates an inviting ambiance that is perfect for date night or a special celebration. Whether you’re a pizza connoisseur or just looking for a break from the ordinary, Revolver Pizza is sure to impress.

Locations: Moundsville & New Martinsville

See PJ’s Pizza’s Menu

pjs pizza

PJ’s Pizza is a cozy, family-friendly pizzeria that offers a wide range of delicious pizza options, from classic favorites to inventive new creations. Their extensive menu, which includes gluten-free and vegan options, ensures there’s something for everyone. With friendly service and a comfortable atmosphere, PJ’s Pizza is a perfect spot for a family dinner or a casual night out with friends.

One of the standout features of PJ’s Pizza is their commitment to accommodating the dietary needs and preferences of all customers. Their gluten-free crust and vegan cheese options ensure that everyone can enjoy a delicious pizza, no matter their restrictions. In addition to the traditional pizza offerings, PJ’s also features a selection of calzones, strombolis, and sandwiches, providing a variety of choices for even the pickiest of eaters. For those looking to complement their meal, PJ’s offers a lineup of tempting appetizers, such as their famous garlic breadsticks or spinach and artichoke dip. The welcoming and relaxed atmosphere at PJ’s Pizza, combined with its diverse menu, makes it an ideal destination for a memorable meal with loved ones.

Brother’s Pizza #

Locations: Hanover, Gettysburg, McSherrystown, York

See Brother’s Pizza’s Menu

brothers pizza

Brother’s Pizza is all about bringing people together through the love of pizza. Established by two siblings who share an unwavering passion for creating the perfect pie, this popular spot has been serving the community with mouthwatering hand-tossed, thin-crust pizzas for years. The warm, inviting atmosphere at Brother’s Pizza is reminiscent of a family gathering, making it the perfect place to enjoy a casual get-together with friends and loved ones.

The menu at Brother’s Pizza offers a wide selection of pies, each made with the freshest ingredients available. Crowd-pleasers like the BBQ chicken pizza, with its tangy sauce and tender chicken, and the veggie supreme, loaded with an array of colorful vegetables and flavorful cheeses, are only a few of the exceptional choices available. The pizzeria also offers customizable pies, allowing customers to create their dream pizza from a long list of toppings. With options for everyone, from meat lovers to vegetarians, Brother’s Pizza consistently delivers on taste and quality.

Pizza Luna #

Location: New Orleans

See Pizza Luna’s Menu

Pizza Luna

Pizza Luna elevates the humble pizza to an art form with its artisanal, wood-fired pies and stylish atmosphere. This upscale pizzeria stands out as a trendy dining destination, offering a unique twist on the traditional pizza experience. Pizza Luna’s cozy yet chic interior, complete with exposed brick walls, ambient lighting, and lush greenery, sets the stage for a memorable night out.

What truly sets Pizza Luna apart from the competition is its creative approach to toppings and flavor combinations. The fig and prosciutto pizza, with its sweet and salty juxtaposition, is a must-try for adventurous diners. Likewise, the spicy shrimp pizza is a harmonious blend of heat and succulent seafood that will leave you craving more. Beyond the innovative pizza offerings, the extensive menu features a variety of salads, appetizers, and desserts, ensuring that there’s something for everyone to enjoy.

Conclusion #

The USA is home to an incredible variety of pizzerias, each offering their own unique spin on this beloved dish. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic New York-style slice, a gourmet Neapolitan pie, or something completely unexpected, you’re sure to find the perfect pizzeria to satisfy your cravings in 2023. If you’re a true pizza enthusiast, consider embarking on a pizza tour across the country to sample the many diverse styles and flavors that American pizzerias have to offer.

And if you’re feeling inspired by the creative pies you’ve discovered along the way, why not try making your own Jamie Oliver Yoghurt Pizza for a fun and inventive take on a classic? With a little imagination and a love for pizza, the possibilities are endless.